The Battle Against Trial Lawyers

I was shocked to find a recent headline in the Newproducts liability cases, such as cases against drug
York Times business section one morning about themanufacturers, the expenses can run into the millions. If
recent trend among business and insurance lobbyistsa lawyer's ability to be compensated under a
to restrict your rights.contingent fee agreement for assuming this risk is
This is yet another chapter in a battle that has beenlimited by state legislation, the simple fact is that fewer
raging for more than 20 years as national Chamber ofattorneys will be able to handle these types of cases
Commerce organizations, multi-national corporationson a contingency basis - and this is what the business
and insurance industry insiders decided that theirinterests really are seeking to accomplish.
bottom lines would improve if they could somehowThe business lobby hopes that the state legislatures
avoid costly lawsuits from people who are seriouslywill start restricting the contingency percentage that an
injured when their products or actions cause harm.attorney can charge to the point that it is not
Arguably, some states have had a history of wildlyeconomically viable for a lawyer to take an injury case
outrageous jury verdicts - but that was a long time inon a contingency.
the past and certainly not in Colorado. It is alsoThey say that we can still charge our clients an hourly
irrefutable that certain bad elements among the trialfee to work on the case therefore nobody will be
lawyers have tarnished the good work that the rest ofharmed by these types of laws. However, the reality is
us try to do on a daily basis. However, the fact is thatthat very few accident victims can afford to pay an
the insurance industry is trying to push the bar furtherhourly fee and certainly cannot do so if they have
away from being equal and fair to all parties to thesuffered a catastrophic injury, are facing hundreds of
point that small people like you and me will never facethousands of dollars in medical care and cannot work.
a fair playing field in the event we are injured and haveI find it ironic that the business lobby is saying that we
to sue a large corporation.trial attorneys make too much money in a time when
The current method of restricting your rights is to tryexecutive compensation packages at large
and push for legislation to limit the amount of attorney'scorporations are going through the roof. It disgusts me
fees that us trial lawyers can charge when we taketo think that a CEO of a large company can make
on a case on a contingency basis. It is a greatmillions of dollars per year and even be entitled to
approach. Lets face it, on the surface it sounds like itmillion dollar buyout packages when they run their
will benefit the accident victims more than anyone else.companies into the ground. How much do they really
However, in reality, serious restrictions in the amount ofcare about you and I when they plunder their
fees charged by attorneys will severely limit injuredemployees' pension funds to support their bad
persons' choices when hiring a lawyer.business decisions yet still collect such exorbitant
Accident law is a business. Even us trial lawyers havesalaries?
to be able to make a profit on what we do. WhatLet me be clear that I, as a personal injury lawyer,
makes us trial lawyers unique is the extremely highcertainly do have cases where I am handsomely
degree of risk that we have to assume on behalf ofcompensated for my time. However, I also have
our clients. In nearly all accident cases, a lawyer doescases where I barely break even, or even lose money.
not get paid until and unless he or she gets a recoveryThese are the risks I take. If I find I can make more
for their client. If there is no recovery, then the attorneymoney charging an hourly fee in another area of law -
will not be paid for the hundreds or thousands of hoursI will be forced to do it. I, and the other trial attorneys
that they can spend working on a complex case.throughout the country will be fine regardless. The
Trial lawyers often spend tens of thousands of dollarsinjured people will be the ones left holding the bag and
from their own pockets to bring their client's cases tonothing would make the business and insurance
trial. These trial expenses can be tens of thousands oflobbyists happier.
dollars on even a simple auto accident case. In large