Does Intelligent Speed Adaptation (ISA) Promote Safe Driving?

With a six-month test of intelligent speed adaptationevents and inclement weather.
(ISA) in London underway this summer, this newOptical recognition - This technology uses roadside
automotive technology is getting plenty of press. Thesigns to broadcast speed limit data to a car. As a
test began as a way to prevent government-owneddriver passes a sign, the information is received and
vehicles from speeding, thereby promoting safe drivingcompared with the vehicle's current speed. The speed
and a host of other benefits.would remain in effect until the car passes a new sign.
For example, according to several studies, using thisBecause the system does not work without the
technology could reduce the number of car accidentsroadside signs, optical recognition can be problematic in
by as much as 25 percent. In fact, the UK Externalareas where large distances exist between signs.
Vehicle Speed Control (EVSC) project estimates thatDead reckoning - To use dead reckoning, a car must
auto accident related fatalities could be reduced by asbegin its journey at a predetermined location. As the
much as 59 percent, too.car drives, dead reckoning uses mathematical
Developed in France in 1982, intelligent speedcalculations based on the rotation of the wheels, angle
adaptation is a term better recognized in Europe,of the steering wheel and other data gathered by
where several tests and studies have beenspecial sensors to discover its current location. Then it
conducted. If you are not already familiar with intelligentcompares the speed limit in the current location against
speed adaptation, take a few moments to learn whatthe speed of the car.
it is, as well as how works, and the pros and cons ofCriticism of intelligent speed adaptation
imposing widespread use.Of course, the first barrier to adoption of intelligent
What is intelligent speed adaptation?speed adaptation is human. Rules like these often
ISA constantly checks and compares a vehicle'salienate the public. Feelings aside, however, there are
speed to the legal limit. When a driver exceeds thetwo primary flaws with intelligent speed adaptation that
speed limit, the device takes either a passive action,prevents a barrier to widespread use. The first are
such as sending a warning to the driver, or an activeproblems properly determining a driver's location. For
one, like automatically slowing the car to the legal limit.example, GPS-based intelligent speed adaptation will
Some intelligent speed adaptation systems have annot work when drivers are in underground tunnels. In
override device. Those that do not are consideredaddition, tall buildings, trees and cloud coverage can
mandatory. Ideally, ISA can identify when drivers enterinterfere and weaken the signal.
a new speed zone, even those that are temporaryThe human factor is the other flaw with intelligent
(because of an accident, special event or construction)speed adaptation. For example, studies show that
or variable depending on the time of day, like schooldrivers with ISA drive more aggressively. First, they
zones.leave less stopping distance between cars. In addition,
How does intelligent speed adaptation work?these drivers often maintain a higher rate of speed,
GPS is the most common technology used to powerrather than slowing down in areas they did before the
ISA systems. Satellites are used to triangulate aintelligent speed adaptation was added to their car.
driver's position and speed. The ISA compares theTherefore, critics suggest that focusing on automation
data to a digital map that contains data about localthat aids driver technique, rather than forces them to
speed limits, including information around variable speedbehave in a certain way, will be more effective.
zones. Because real-time updates can be made, it hasBenefits of intelligent speed adaptation
the ability to adjust on the fly. Other types ofOf course, the largest benefit of intelligent speed
technology used for intelligent speed adaptation include:adaptation is a drop in the amount, as well as the
Radio beacons - A receiver inside the car picks upseverity, of motor vehicle accidents. Ideally, this
data broadcast by roadside radio beacons. Thesecorrelates into fewer fatalities, as well as lowers the
beacons can provide information about local speedcost associated with repairs and medical treatment.
limits, as well as any variable and temporary changesTheoretically, this should lower the cost of car
to the limits. Beacons would need to link to ainsurance, too. How this new technology could be
mainframe computer to promote real-time updates,imposed is still being determined, but one theory is that
and placed regularly along routes to calculate speedyou could receive a discount on your car insurance
properly. To override signals from fixed beacons,premium by having it installed.
mobile beacons could be used during accident, special