Challenging the Breath Test in Court

A breathalyzer or breath test result showing a bloodenvironmental, biological, and physical circumstances. A
alcohol concentration (BAC) over the legal limit can betest administered by an untrained police officer may
one of the most damaging pieces of evidence in theproduce inaccurate or unreliable readings.
context of a driving while intoxicated (DWI) or drivingAbsorption Defense
under the influence (DUI) trial. Though damaging,The absorption of alcohol into the bloodstream takes
however, breathalyzer evidence is not ironclad. Atime. By some estimates, it may take up to two hours
variety of factors may cause false or inaccuratefor consumed alcohol to reach equilibrium distribution
readings, allowing DWI defense lawyers to challengethroughout the body. Breathalyzer tests administered
their reliability in court.during this period can produce inaccurate results, since
Common ways to dispute breathalyzer test resultsalcohol content is inconsistent in different areas of the
include:body. Furthermore, if alcohol has not yet been
Calibration Errorabsorbed into the bloodstream, it does not contribute
Like any machine, breathalyzers degrade and becometo a person's level of intoxication.
less sensitive over time. Proper calibration is needed toBiological Variables
ensure that results are accurate. Evidence that aBreath test results are based on a standard
machine was not properly adjusted and/or maintainedmathematical formula which relates the amount of
may discredit its results.alcohol on a person's breath with the amount of
Operator Qualificationsalcohol present in their bloodstream. This formula,
In most states, strict laws are in place to regulate thehowever, only applies when all biological variables
operation and maintenance of breath test machines.conform to its standards. The ratio of breath alcohol to
Because these devices are very sensitive, operatorsblood alcohol varies between individuals and over time;
must be properly trained to adapt to differentvariations in body temperature can also affect results.